Climate Exceptionalism and the Forward on Climate Rally

(The following is an article written by our friend and ally from Philadelphia. She recently attended the “Forward on Climate” in Washington D.C., and offers some insightful and challenging analysis to the climate movement. Enjoy!)

Climate Exceptionalism and the Forward on Climate Rally
M Schlotterbeck

As I’m helping organize buses to the “Forward on Climate” rally in D.C., I can’t but feel deep reservations about it. A recent article by 350’s President, Bill McKibben, has hung in my mind because it encapsulates the hope and power of 350’s campaign, as well and the ignorance of movement history and endemic elitism that pervades some parts of mainstream climate organizing. McKibben treats climate work as a completely exceptional case, as more urgent than other work for justice, and in the process sabotages the possibility of fostering a real movement.

Rather than seeing climate activism as part of broader struggles against domination of the many by the few (i.e. the Left), McKibben frames it as a completely separate thing. It’s “the greatest problem we’ve ever faced. It’s not a fight, like education reform or abortion or gay marriage, between conflicting groups with conflicting opinions.” Everyone should work on nothing except climate change because, essentially, everything else can wait. This is climate exceptionalism, the idea that climate work is separate from and above other work for justice. Such a claim to some trophy for “most urgent issue” is dismissive toward movements all over the globe fighting for basic survival and dignity, and for other desperately needed structural change. But the question to be asking is not whether climate change is actually worse than genocide or wars or prisons or the systematic exploitation of most of the world’s people for profit, but why do we even need to compare and rank the problems? Would climate change be less of a problem if we decided genocide was actually worse? Would we be closer to overcoming either of them? What does it accomplish other than give people working on climate change a sense of unjustified superiority over other movements?

To read the rest of the article, click here


One thought on “Climate Exceptionalism and the Forward on Climate Rally

  1. I have to completely agree with this, yes climate change is an important struggle, but in the scheme of things, the tar sands problems are just if not more important, due to the fact that the most basic source of life will be destroyed!!
    Yes, to fighting for the Climate, but indeed, Yes to the greater struggle of preserving our planet from those life destroying Tar Sands!! This therein is a much larger struggle and should never be co-opted by those in a cozy relationship with D.C.!!
    One can understand Bill McKibbens passion and concern, but indeed it is not the be-all issue…
    Certainly he is appreciated for all he does, but those “bottom of the energy barrel” Tar Sands are destroying the human race far faster than the air we breathe…
    As a victim of the worst oil spill in history, I have first hand knowledge of just what oil can do, also as a victim of the most devastating “land loss” in the U.S. it is easy to testify what the horrors of Big Oil is capable of..
    For me, the supreme objective is to stop those Tar Sands projects everywhere, not only in North America, but indeed, the world…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s